“Now All Big Smart Boys don’t let us skin them – let us milk them.” Petty pay as you play, and then… you just didn’t match. Russian men call it “Dynamo”, meaning bad-faith “consummation”. What’s ironic is that the “normal” traditional Eastern dating, or e-dating, procedure begins the same way.
The difference is in the result… and in subtlest red flags on the way, which your good auld Natalia’s there to tell.
Greater irony is that man can even feel grateful for every moment of being “used”! These Special Russian Women.™
(Or it takes a special man to choose enlightenment against despair?)
Thank a client who authorized me to tell his story on one finest Dynamo machine business for Ukraine. It looked [almost] innocent for as long as two dozen letters. But “however long a rope weaves, it comes to an end”.
- Here’s the by-tale, the tale would follow.
Decent brides or scam agencies, – both proceed from the following basics of Russian etiquette, dealing with the material side of arranging meetings, dates and communication.
* Whose the initiative, his the bill. (Between friends, pals, business partners.)
* Whose more money, his the bill. (Close friends meeting, or the traditional “alpha” competition.)
* Who’s the Man, his the bill. (If not let to pay, he takes offense.) This may go as far as his cancelling the girl’s incoming mobile call, just to redial her at his own cost. In international phone talks, it’s an axiom.
Of course, Dutch treats are an acceptable alternative, – if the beneficiary steps forward, and the benefactor doesn’t object. Usually the situation turns into a pretty competition: “I am treating!” – “Let me pay!” Like two proverbial gentlemen stuck before the doors insisting that the other should go first. The beneficiary resists, the benefactor persists, and, after a ritual of tribute to Good Manner, the dispute settles by the rules stated above. (Or Dutch.)
Remember that, in the Russian tradition, the offeror of a favor must not accept refusal from it until the offeree has objected thrice. The first two times are a ritual of modesty, and a test to the offeror’s determination.
Ladies tend to over-caution about accepting treats and gifts. In the characteristic anecdote, a Georgian man (USSR, not USA) – portrayed as an epitome of macho temper, vain lavishness, and not a master of Russian grammar – says: “I dine ze gurl – I dance ze gurl!” (Implying all actions that follow.) So, Russian women strive to not produce a false impression of accessibility in exchange for courtship.
* Still, there is a cultural norm of common courtesy to bring small gifts to people you are visiting from far away, and even for their relatives. Commemorating holidays, especially birthdays, with gifts and/or flowers, – is a must. It means you are Serious and Appreciative of the connection that develops.
At the stage of online dating, e-cards and attachments do. (Please take care not to over-burden her Internet traffic with kilobytes of graphic and video.) Real flowers or gifts, if you decide to send them, are a dear surprise… Almost unexpected (though dream is always there!) and therefor exciting.
WARNING: flower delivery service, sold as a proof of the woman’s existence, may not be such. A scam agency may take a poor quality “natural” photo that looks like any female of similar type, or depict your correspondent from their “boiler room” described below.
* With regard to the national Givers’ Culture and the bridal Provider Test, - making or not making Acts of Expense (including treats, gifts, flowers, travel expenses and the rest of logistics) are a kind of exercise in drawing the fine line between the red flags of “Buying Her”, “Scroodging On Her” and “Intimating To Her”. The algorythm is to be generous without arrogance and familiarity.
And of course these Mysterious Russian Ladies never prod you toward it apparently. They are usually prepared to bear their own expense, to reasonable “emergency” extent.
When you know her paying something for the introduction service, it’s usually a sign of serious determination to find a worthy husband. Yet normally, with all the free alternatives she is offered, this “something” is not overtaxing her pocket and effort. Otherwise, start thinking: Cui Prodest?
The party who wins always: The House. Just like in any Web search, gamble, stock exchange, legal arbitration etc. (We have agreed to not frown at applying analogies from economics to the Merger of Values accounted at the Heavenly Chancery.)
- This is what you should be alert to when you deal with agencies that serve an interface between the Ladies and the outer world, arranging profile listings, translations, gifts and dates.
- Now the fairy tale with a “horror” happy end.
“A. contacted me on ["site.com"]. This is based in Canada and has mostly Canadian members. It’s probably a good site for FSU and other foreign women to use, because there’s no monthly fee or listing fee, and you only pay per message you initiate. You can also send a “smile” for free to show interest in someone, which is what A. did.
I wasn’t very active on it, just looking and dreaming. I didn’t even have a description of myself posted, other than the fill-in-the-blanks stuff. Anyway… I had gotten 2 other smiles from Ukraine but wasn’t interested. I expected to feel the same when I saw her “smile”, but I was captured by her direct and heartfelt description of herself, and things I could go on and on about in her eyes and face!”
Checkpoint. “Normal” women get first interested in a candidate by his profile: thoughtfully vast, or powerfully laconical, but not ordinarily careless, and of course they do serious “face control”. The factors that normally attract interest to a scanty and unpersonalized profile, are the man’s great looks and/or successful occupation.
“So we exchanged a few emails, and I liked her more and more. She told me she was writing through a translation service ["agency.com"]. I went to their site and it seems to be a legitimate professional business. I saw their translation rates and arranged to pay for the first few translations. Their payments are processed by a company in the US.”
Bummer. Even if there’s no scam, dealing with such non-speakers that can’t at least read in your language is a problem in itself. Especially when intelligent and sociable persons are involved. Explained here
“I’ve read that there are so-called “translation services” that are actually scam centers. I’m having trouble figuring out how that would be a profitable scam, with the relatively small amount of money involved, compared to other methods. It strikes me as like fishing in the shallow end of the lake for minnows using caviar as bait. When 100 meters away you can catch fish big enough to feed a family, using raw hamburger. (Although, as you’ll see, they are charging me for translating letters that are mostly translated already. But oh well..)”
Legal niche. The highest tide for big scam has gone. “Raw meat market” is full, rotting and smelling around. Of a hundred men, few go farther than correspondence. So the prevailing strategy in the current introduction industry is a non-criminable symbiosis of hope and profit, with decent target audience of customers and even decent intentions, but not by totally decent methods.
Many agencies pay their female members for every letter they receive or write, to encourage their activity, to keep men’s interest, the traffic, and… the turnover. At the fleeting glance, everybody is contented. A woman may seriously count on coming across the man of her life this way (this hope attends any woman employed in the international service sector), and put up with writing to more men she’s currently happened to get interested in, – especially as she knows that it may take many “glances” to “see” a person, and can enjoy the opportunities of improving her international communication skills. (Justly, doing her job, without personal interest, is only distancing her from the great goal.)
The only question is, whether YOU are a man of her advanced interest, or a “milk cow”.
“One thing I soon noticed was a slight sense of disconnect, not a real smooth flow in our conversation back and forth. Although what she wrote told me a lot about her personally, and didn’t seem to have an agenda behind it, it often wasn’t a response to anything I had said. More like a mini-essay on something she wanted to tell me this time. Of course, I like to read what she writes, and she tells me who she really is inside, which I value. But if I ask her some simple questions about her and her life, she might respond with a short answer, she might answer 2 out of 4 questions, or none at all, and then on to the “topic of the day”. Or she’ll start by simply saying, “Thank for telling me about such-and-such”. Although – if I ask her something important, like whether she’s thought about what it would be like to be separated from her home and family, and practical considerations of relocating, she gives a thoughtful answer.
Approach. At times, shyness to intrude, to expose, to contradict, even to break the literary flow of the letter, and also lack of language skills to understand the sense of certain phrases of yours, may keep a Russian woman from responding to some of your questions or statements. But I fully agree that such behavior, even if not evil-rooted, is inconsistent with serious attitude, and would also disqualify a mate-to-be who “listens” only to him/herself.
If you reiterate or reformulate a topic your respondent has left unanswered, she ought to honor it at least by an allusion, joke, inclusive answer. (So should you!) In turn, repetition owed to the writer’s own forgetful multitasking exposes scam in a woman’s letter, and discredits a man.
“Now – a few days ago I came across something quite by accident that, on the one hand, explained the form of her letters and some of the un-responded-to questions. But on the other hand, set me back on my heels…”
Part II. “Too-Good-To-Be-True” Black Lists
© Comrade Natalia
(…please link to this page when using some information from it! ;)




January 14, 2007 at 9:53 pm
Just follow this simple guide and you can’t go wrong :)
Q. I contacted a woman on a dating site. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. Why would a real woman post an ad on a dating site? She posted an ad to ask you for money later.
Q. A woman contacted me on a dating site. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. Why would a woman contact you on a dating site? She did it to ask you for money later.
Q. I started corresponding with this woman and she replies. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She is replying to you because she wants to ask you for money later. Why would a real woman reply to you?
Q. This woman stopped writing to me. Is she a scammer?
A. Definitely. She was afraid that you would find her out.
Q. This woman sends me her photos. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. All scammers send photos with every e-mail.
Q. This woman sent me a couple of photos and then stopped sending them. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She stole these photos from somewhere and ran out of them.
Q. She tells me that she has a family: father, mother and a brother. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She tells you about her family to ask you for money because someone is ill.
Q. The woman tells me that she has no family. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She will ask you for money later because she will be in trouble and have no one to help her.
Q. The woman tells me that she has no phone. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She will ask you for money to install a phone.
Q. The woman tells me that she has a phone. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She wants to play you up and show you that she is “real”, then she will ask you for money.
Q. The woman told me that she did not know any English. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes, later on she will ask you for money to pay for English lessons.
Q. The woman told me that she knows English. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She learned English while scamming others.
Q. The woman told me that she would like to meet me in person. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She will ask you to send her money for visa and tickets.
Q. The woman told me that she wanted to meet me in person and asked me to visit her. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. When you visit, she will ask you for money.
Q. I visited this woman and we went to a restaurant. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She took you to a restaurant to scam you for money.
Q. I went home and we still keep contact. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes, she talks to you because she wants to ask you for money later.
Q. I proposed and she accepted. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. Scammers usually accept when you propose. Why would a normal woman accept you?
Q. We are doing our paperwork and I paid for it. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. You were scammed for the paperwork fee. A real woman would have paid hers and your own.
Q. She got her visa and is coming to the country. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She scammed you for the visa.
Q. We got married. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. Why would a real woman marry you? She did it to ask you for money later.
Q. She got her residency. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She did it to ask you for money later.
Q. She got her ten years card. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. She did it to ask you for money later.
Q. She got her citizenship. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes, now she will be asking you for money.
Q. She found out that I was posting here, read my posts and left. Is she a scammer?
A. Yes. You were scammed for citizenship!
Q. I am trying to find someone again. I posted my ad on a dating site and a woman contacted me. Is she a scammer? …
from
http://www.rwguide.com/forums/topic.cfm?topic=2497&page=1
March 30, 2008 at 1:32 am
I just got a heartbreaking confession from a friend and future client, who was scammed for visa and ticket by a “children’s surgeon, 34, Kazan”. Same old story? No, a new stage of its evolution, so to say, Russian Scam 2.0. The difference was in his qualities, far above average, and in the pace of their online & telephone relationship – intensive but slowly deepening to what seemed genuine, personal care. Looks like finer customers get finer-tuned “treatment”, and long slow tangle is no longer warranty of safety.
But meet Russian Scam 3.0. This is an original article with illustrations.
Late in 2006, Alexey Goncharenko (at the photo), an attorney in Voronezh, received an email from Sergey Yeliseev, an economic security official at a Moscow airport, as a follow-up of the inquiry by Italian national Antonio Ponini: why hasn’t Yelena Kalinina, Alexey’s client, arrived to Italy?
Yelena and Antonio had met at a dating site and corresponded for two months. Then she said she was ready to visit for closer acquaintance. She didn’t ask money for the visa, nor for the ticket. Just named the day and flight. The Italian was at the airport just on time, but in vain. 3 hours later he got an email, in English, signed by Attorney Goncharenko, notifying that Yelena was detained by custom officers at the airport in Moscow. Kalinina, the email told, was trying to take a valuable icon with her, as a blessing from her Granny. And to bail her out, Antonio ought to pay a certain amount to a certain account. Having done so, the man took further interest in Yelena’s fate. Sergey Yeliseev was charged with investigating the incident.
To Alexey Goncharenko, this was big news. He knew no Yelena Kalinina. His name turned out to have been taken randomly from the Internet, by scammer(s).
“I got the Italian’s email with the girl’s international passport scan and the “attorney’s message” attached, – tells Sergey. Experts have concluded that the passport (at the photo) is an obvious fake.
“I replied to Antonio that the customs had no record of detaining any Yelena Kalinina; that Attorney Goncharenko had never written to him; and that all that was most certainly a scam. We had a similar case with “Granny’s icon” in May. Having mentioned this, I asked Antonio to report to police, so that they informed their Russian colleagues.
“As an airport economic security officer, I know how such scam ends. First, the hapless foreign grooms send us petitions: “What are you doing there in Russia? Why are you keeping the girl incarcerated, I’ve sent the money! I’ll complain to the UNO!” Then they calm down. Piety aside, in 9 of 10 cases such acquaintances start from the click on a banner at a porn site. Our law enforcement bodies are not much concerned. For to initiate a case, the victim must file a complaint to them. But the victims don’t hurry to come out.
“For the past year, we’ve got over 30 letters like Antonio’s. This is a new know-how of marriage scammers. The amounts range from USD 500 to GBP 17000.
“First, trust is fostered. When the groom is ripe, the bride says she’s ready to visit. “I’ll pay my way, you just settle me at your place, so as I save on the hotel.” Before departure, she tells the number of the flight. Then the foreigner receives a message that his love was arrested at the customs, for exporting a grandmother’s icon or an antique engagement ring, and a bribe is needed to have her released. One groom was told that his bride got into a car crash, and money is needed for hospital treatment.
“Why would he send money? Passenger lists are confidential, a layman can’t check them.”
Ouch… For more than a year, I’d been in contact with a nice Canadian man. Serious talks and humorous fantasies in vast emails and dense chat, some phonecalls, a webcam session on his part, vacation plans (Italy to Canada), – a perfect example of a promising beginning. Due to work and business projects, our plans were constantly confused. When I had just gained independence from employment and the prospects of my own agency were more like wishful thinking, I was considering immigration to Canada on the skilled workforce quota, and he was eager to extend his hospitality… None had traveled, none had paid. My developments in Ukraine turned out more urgent than his electronic impulses – or maybe I was just scared of responsibility for becoming a second woman to his wonderful and wayward little princess daughter… “Bear”, please forgive me if I’ve scratched your heart.
April 10, 2008 at 4:04 pm
Wow, that is such a lot to go through for money. It must be a large amount for the effort, even for a scammer? That is very amazing. And eye-opening.
:(